John wrote:PiersEIN wrote:Mister Moon wrote:John wrote:I'm not sure what you have against stereo, against hearing each instrument clearly, which you certainly can't do with mono when instruments are hidden behind each other, and when vocals are sometimes hidden behind the instruments.
Have you heard the new Beatles Red and Blue albums?
Simply put, I have nothing against true stereo. I don't like mono recordings being tampered with.
Incidentally, I was listening to The Beatles' YouTube channel this very afternoon, to some of the new mixes featured in the new Red and Blue versions. It's undeniable that the overall sound is great, but those songs have always sounded great to me, in the original George Martin mixes, mono or stereo. I don't like the fact that some elements are, again, arbitrarily moved front or back to create a new sound image that has nothing to do with the original concept developed by Martin and the band. For example, who is to say that the cowbell in "You Can't Do That" has to be almost totally removed ? It's one of the coolest features in one of the coolest Beatles tracks ever, in my opinion. Stuff like that is what I don't like.
There is no doubt that SONY / RCA are now looking at the success of Apple / Universal flogging The Beatles Red & Blue compilations all over again.
At some point we will get a new ELVIS compilation with the marketing of "Now with Elvis' Greatest HITS all in TRUE STEREO - for the very first time!"
ERIC records do a great job, as does Anthony Stuchbury with his recent efforts.
get Vic Anesini or Ray Bardani to do the high-quality ReMastering and I'll buy it.
Cheers
Piers
Mr Stuchbury's work is already top notch. It's hard to see how it can be improved upon.
in the audio engineering world there's always room for improvement.